Here’s why Nvidia, Microsoft and other ‘Magnificent Seven’ stocks are back on top in 2024

By comparison, the Magnificent Seven added a total of $5.117 trillion in market cap in 2023 while the S&P 500 added $6.502 trillion, per Dow Jones Market Data. Nvidia, the best-performing member of the elite group of tech stocks, gained nearly 240% last year, FactSet data show.

Once again in the new year, Nvidia and Microsoft Corp.
MSFT,
+1.84%
have drawn much of investors’ interest in artificial intelligence, with both companies seen by strategists and portfolio managers as the de facto leaders of the AI boom.

Both of these stocks were on track to finish Wednesday at record highs, with Microsoft briefly seeing its market capitalization top $3 trillion for the first time. Nvidia, meanwhile, was on track to finish Wednesday’s session with a market cap north of $1.5 trillion for the first time.

But why — after a brief sojourn late last year that briefly saw small-caps and other underappreciated corners of the market play catch up — has Big Tech made such a durable comeback, while other sectors of the market have struggled to hold on to their late-2023 gains?

Several portfolio managers and market strategists who spoke with MarketWatch for this story shared a similar explanation.

According to Jay Hatfield, CEO and portfolio manager at Infrastructure Capital Advisors, Big Tech names tend to outperform when investors are betting on higher interest rates or rethinking expectations for aggressive interest-rate cuts, as investors have done recently.

“There is an urban myth that tech stocks are more interest-rate sensitive than other stocks, but that is actually not true,” Hatfield said.

This ability to outperform despite higher interest rates stems from Big Tech firms’ low debt levels, stable cash flows and above-trend earnings growth.

“Higher rates don’t increase their cost of capital, and they’re not derailing growth expectations since these companies have higher growth rates than most of the economy,” said Rob Haworth, senior investment strategy director at U.S. Bank Wealth Management.

Still, that Nvidia has risen another 25% since the beginning of January has taken many on Wall Street by surprise — especially those who had expected a rotation favoring small-cap stocks and unprofitable technology names, like those that benefited the most during the fourth-quarter rally.

But while the Magnificent Seven are once again dominating the league tables, Hatfield pointed out that the situation in the new year doesn’t exactly mirror what happened in 2023.

For instance, two members of the group have notably lagged in the new year. Tesla Inc.
TSLA,
-0.50%,
which reports earnings after the bell on Wednesday, has been trailing behind its megacap peers, falling 16% this year to date through Wednesday’s close, according to FactSet data.

Weakness in Tesla and tepid performance by Apple Inc.
AAPL,
-0.54%
have led Hatfield and others to propose that the “Fabulous Five” — Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon.com Inc.
AMZN,
+7.87%,
Alphabet Inc.
GOOGL,
+0.86%

GOOG,
+0.58%
and Meta Platforms Inc.
META,
+20.32%
— probably makes more sense than the “Magnificent Seven” at this point.

Investors would probably be better served by taking these five stocks, plus a handful of other AI names like Broadcom Inc.
AVGO,
+2.03%
and Advanced Micro Devices Inc.
AMD,
+4.21%,
and grouping them together in a basket that’s more focused on the AI theme, Hatfield added.

“I think the real story is artificial intelligence, not just the Mag 7,” Hatfield told MarketWatch. “And where the AI boom is unfolding is in the cloud and chips.”

As for what has helped push these stocks back into a position of market leadership, Hatfield believes that it’s mainly the result of investors rethinking expectations for aggressive interest-rate cuts set to begin in the coming months.

While small-cap stocks need lower interest rates and a higher-growth environment to thrive, the megacap tech companies are well-positioned to succeed in any environment.

And although valuation is certainly an issue for the Big Tech names, neither Hatfield nor Haworth believes these stocks are overvalued at current levels.

In fact, as Haworth pointed out, the forward price-to-earnings ratio on the Nasdaq-100
NDX
— which, of the major U.S. indexes, is most heavily weighted toward megacap tech — presently stands at around 25. That is well below 30, where the index traded back in 2020.

The Invesco QQQ Trust Series 1
QQQ,
an ETF that tracks the Nasdaq-100, rose 0.6% to close at $425.83 per share Wednesday.

Although few of the megacap tech names have yet reported earnings for the final three months of 2023, chip stocks like Nvidia have gotten a boost from the strong guidance and rosy numbers shared by Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co.
TSM,
+2.08%
when the world’s largest contract chip maker reported earnings earlier this month.

Still, few expect that the S&P 500 can power higher forever without the rally broadening out at some point. Hatfield said he expects to see broader participation once the Fed starts cutting interest rates later this year.

To be sure, there are still some skeptics who believe the market’s overreliance on a handful of technology names could create problems in the not-too-distant future.

Barry Bannister, a longtime market strategist at Stifel, pointed out in comments emailed to MarketWatch that narrow, growth-led markets existed in 1929, 1972 and 1999 — and all of them ended badly with crashes in 1930, 1973 and 2000.

“What seemed like a good idea at the time ended in tears for investors,” Bannister said.